Witch trials, family secrets, and an unsettling mystery collide in one of her most enjoyable books yet.
There are books that make you forget all your plans for the evening, because you just have to know what happens next. For me, The Witch was one of those books. I raced through this one in a matter of a few sittings, totally absorbed in the eerie atmosphere, family secrets and mystery at the heart of the story.
This time Freida McFadden deviates from her usual psychological thrillers and delivers something that feels surprisingly fresh. The story is told in dual timelines and dual points of view, following Julia in the present day and Caroline in the Salem witch trial era. As the two storylines begin to collide, old secrets begin to surface and long-buried truths start to demand attention.
The atmosphere worked particularly well for me. The haunted house is wonderfully unsettling without being overwhelming, and there is always the feeling that something is just below the surface. Between the bizarre happenings, the unsettling family relationships, and the dark history that won’t stay buried, I was totally engrossed in the story.
I also loved the dual timelines. The two stories felt just as captivating, which is unusual. Every time the point of view changed, I was more interested in knowing more, not wishing to get back to the other story. Caroline’s chapters were especially interesting, adding historical depth and emotional weight to the mystery.
I thought the mix of historical fiction, suspense, and supernatural was just right.
Having said that, my biggest frustration was the ending. After such a strong buildup, it all felt a little too wrapped up too quickly. The twists were entertaining and mostly took me by surprise, but I wanted more room to sit with the reveals. By the last page I was not disappointed, just wishing the story had taken a little longer to breathe.
But I had a great time with The Witch. McFadden delivers the suspense and page-turning excitement that readers have come to expect from her books, but this seems like a nice change of pace for her. If you like witchy vibes, dual timelines, family secrets, and fast-paced mysteries, this is a good addition to your autumn reading list.
I am grateful for this copy from Penguin Random House South Africa. However, my review opinions are my own!
Also read:
The Divorce by Freida McFadden: A Masterclass in Chaos
